What To Do With Jewelry From an Ex? [+5 Real Stories]

What To Do With Jewelry From an Ex? [+5 Real Stories]

Ending a relationship can be emotionally challenging, and deciding what to do with jewelry from an ex can add another layer of complexity to the healing process.

It’s important to find a solution that feels right for you and allows you to move forward.

Here in this article, we will discuss some suggestions on what you can do, along with stories of how others have successfully moved on.

10 Things To Do With Jewelry From an Ex

Breaking up is never easy, especially when it comes to dealing with the reminders of your past relationship.

One common item that many people struggle with is jewelry from an ex.

It can be difficult to know what to do with these sentimental pieces, but there are plenty of options that can help you move on and make the most out of the situation.

Here are 10 things you can do with jewelry from an ex:

10 Things To Do With Jewelry From an Ex

1. Keep It as a Keepsake

Many individuals opt to retain jewelry from a past relationship as a cherished keepsake.

This piece of jewelry, often imbued with profound memories, serves as a tangible reminder of a significant chapter in their lives.

By placing it in a dedicated box or drawer, they can revisit those memories when they wish, reflecting on the growth, lessons, and moments they experienced.


  • Emotional Connection: The jewelry can serve as a comforting reminder of happy times and personal growth.
  • Historical Value: Over time, it can become a piece of one’s personal history, narrating stories to future generations.


  • Potential Emotional Baggage: For some, it might hinder the healing process, constantly reminding them of past pains or regrets.
  • Misinterpretation: Future partners might misunderstand the intention behind keeping such mementos.

Moving On:

Keeping it as a keepsake allows for controlled reflection.

Instead of erasing the past, one acknowledges it, learns from it and uses those lessons to move forward with resilience and wisdom.

However, it’s essential to ensure that this keepsake doesn’t become an emotional anchor, preventing genuine healing and progress.

2. Wear It Casually

For many, jewelry is more than just a symbol of a past relationship; it’s a piece of art, a testament to craftsmanship, or simply a beautiful accessory.

If wearing the jewelry doesn’t evoke painful memories or negative emotions, there’s no reason not to incorporate it into one’s daily or occasional wear.

By doing so, individuals can detach the item from its original sentimental context and instead appreciate it for its aesthetic value or the joy it brings when worn.


  • Reclaiming the Piece: Wearing it casually allows one to redefine the jewelry’s significance, focusing on its beauty rather than its history.
  • Versatility: Quality jewelry can complement various outfits and occasions, adding elegance or flair to one’s style.
  • Economic Sense: Instead of letting a potentially expensive piece gather dust, one can get regular use out of it.


  • Potential Questions: Friends or acquaintances might recognize the piece and ask about its origin, leading to potentially awkward conversations.
  • Mixed Emotions: Over time, feelings can change. What once felt neutral might evoke unexpected emotions later on.

Embracing the Present:

By choosing to wear the jewelry casually, one is making a conscious decision to live in the present.

It’s a way of saying that while the past has shaped them, it doesn’t define them.

This act can be empowering, signifying control over one’s narrative and choices.

3. Repurpose or Redesign

Transforming jewelry from a past relationship into a fresh design can be both therapeutic and creatively fulfilling.

By repurposing, individuals breathe new life into an item, allowing it to evolve just as they have.

An old engagement ring might find a new purpose as a pendant, or gemstones from a bracelet could be reimagined into elegant earrings.

This process not only gives the jewelry a new aesthetic appeal but also symbolizes personal growth and the ability to move forward, reshaping memories into something new and uniquely personal.


  • Personal Expression: Redesigning allows one to infuse their personal style and preferences into the piece, making it truly their own.
  • Symbolic Transformation: Just as the jewelry is given a new form, individuals can see this as a metaphor for their own evolution and growth post-relationship.
  • Sustainability: Instead of discarding or selling, repurposing is an eco-friendly way to cherish valuable materials and craftsmanship.


  • Cost: Redesigning jewelry can sometimes be expensive, depending on the complexity of the desired design and the jeweler’s fees.
  • Risk of Damage: The process might risk damaging the original piece, especially if it’s antique or delicate.

A New Chapter:

Choosing to repurpose or redesign jewelry is akin to turning the page to a new chapter in one’s life.

It’s a tangible representation of the belief that while the past is immutable, the future is a canvas waiting to be painted with new memories, experiences, and choices.

Related article:

Is It Bad Luck To Wear Jewelry From an Ex? [and 5 Things]

Is It Bad Luck To Wear Jewelry From an Ex Answered

4. Sell or Trade It

For many, the pragmatic approach to dealing with jewelry from a past relationship is to convert it into something of immediate value or utility.

Selling the piece can provide a financial boost, helping with expenses or funding new experiences.

Alternatively, trading it in at a jewelry store can be an excellent way to acquire a new piece that resonates more with one’s current tastes and lifestyle.

This method not only declutters one’s collection but also ensures that the jewelry finds a new home or purpose, rather than languishing unused.


  • Financial Gain: Selling jewelry can provide a welcome influx of cash, which can be used for various purposes, from paying bills to indulging in a treat.
  • Fresh Start: Trading it in for a new piece allows for a symbolic exchange of the old for the new, marking a new beginning.
  • Decluttering: It helps in keeping one’s jewelry collection relevant and streamlined, ensuring each piece is worn and cherished.


  • Potential Regret: Over time, one might feel a sense of loss or regret about parting with a piece that held sentimental value.
  • Market Value: The resale value of jewelry can sometimes be lower than its purchase price or emotional worth.
  • Time-Consuming: Finding the right buyer or platform to sell can take time and effort.

Moving Forward:

Opting to sell or trade jewelry is a testament to one’s ability to prioritize the present and future over the past.

It’s a practical step that signifies readiness to move on, making space for new memories and treasures in one’s life.

5. Gift It to a Loved One

Passing on jewelry to a cherished friend or family member can be a heartwarming way to repurpose a piece that once held a different sentimental value.

By gifting it, the jewelry takes on a new narrative, transitioning from a symbol of past romance to a token of affection and kinship.

This act can be especially meaningful if the recipient admires the piece or if it holds aesthetic or historical significance.

In this way, a piece that might have been a source of pain or nostalgia can become a cherished heirloom, continuing its story in a more positive light.


  • New Narrative: The jewelry gets a fresh start, symbolizing love, friendship, or familial bonds rather than past romantic ties.
  • Preservation: If the piece is of high quality or has historical value, gifting ensures it remains cherished and well-taken care of.
  • Emotional Release: Handing it to someone else can provide emotional relief, severing ties with past memories.


  • Potential Misunderstanding: The recipient might not be aware of the jewelry’s history, leading to potential misconceptions or discomfort if they find out.
  • Emotional Transfer: While the intent is positive, there’s a risk the recipient might also associate the piece with the giver’s past relationship.

Strengthening Bonds:

Choosing to gift jewelry to a loved one is a testament to the strength and importance of other relationships in one’s life.

It’s a gesture that says, “While this chapter has ended, my bond with you endures,” turning a symbol of the past into a beacon of present connections and love.

Based on your interest:

What Does It Mean When Your Ex Keeps Your Gifts? [11 Points]

When Your Ex Keeps Your Gifts

6. Donate It

Choosing to donate jewelry is a noble gesture that transforms a personal item into a beacon of hope and support for others.

By giving it to a charity or organization, the jewelry can be auctioned, sold, or used in ways that generate funds for worthy causes.

This act not only distances the individual from any lingering sentiments tied to the piece but also ensures that its value is channeled toward positive change.

Be it supporting the underprivileged, funding research, or aiding in community projects.


  • Positive Impact: The jewelry’s value can be used to support charitable endeavors, making a tangible difference in the lives of others.
  • Emotional Catharsis: Donating can provide a sense of closure, turning a chapter of personal history into a broader narrative of goodwill.
  • Tax Benefits: In some jurisdictions, charitable donations can be claimed as deductions, providing financial incentives.


  • Irreversible Decision: Once donated, the decision is final, and there might be moments of second-guessing or regret.
  • Research Required: It’s essential to ensure that the chosen charity is reputable and that the donation will be used effectively.

A New Purpose:

Donating jewelry is a testament to one’s ability to look beyond personal experiences and contribute to the greater good.

It’s a step that signifies growth, altruism, and a desire to infuse positivity into the world, making the past a foundation for benevolent actions in the present.

7. Bury or Ritualistic Disposal

For some, the act of physically and symbolically parting with jewelry from a past relationship is a profound step toward healing.

Burying the piece or engaging in a ritualistic disposal can serve as a ceremonial way to bid farewell to past emotions and memories.

This act, often deeply personal, can be rooted in cultural, spiritual, or individual beliefs.

By returning the jewelry to the earth or releasing it through a ritual, individuals create a tangible moment of closure, signifying the end of one chapter and the beginning of another.


  • Symbolic Closure: The act provides a clear, definitive point of letting go, helping in the emotional healing process.
  • Spiritual Connection: For those with spiritual beliefs, this method can offer a sense of peace, as if the universe or a higher power is aiding in their healing journey.
  • Personal Empowerment: Taking control of how to part with the jewelry can be empowering, reinforcing one’s agency over their emotions and choices.


  • Environmental Concerns: Depending on the method and location, burying jewelry might not be environmentally friendly, especially if the piece contains non-biodegradable materials.
  • Permanent Decision: Once carried out, the act is irreversible, and there might be moments of reflection or longing for the piece in the future.
  • Misunderstanding: Those unfamiliar with the individual’s reasons might find the act puzzling or challenging to comprehend.

Embracing the Future:

Opting for a ritualistic disposal or burial is a testament to the depth of human emotion and the lengths one might go to find peace.

It’s a poignant reminder that while objects can hold memories, it’s the act of letting go that often paves the way for new beginnings and personal growth.

Read this next:

Should I Give My Ex His Clothes Back? [The Pros and Cons]

Should I Give My Ex His Clothes Back Answered

8. Exchange With The Ex

In situations where breakups are mutual and amicable, the act of exchanging or returning jewelry can be a meaningful gesture.

It signifies mutual respect, understanding, and an acknowledgment of the bond that once was.

This exchange isn’t just about the physical item but the shared memories and moments it represents.

By returning or exchanging these pieces, both parties can find a sense of closure, ensuring that each individual retains items that resonate with their personal journey, devoid of lingering sentiments.


  • Mutual Closure: The act can provide both parties with a clear endpoint, helping them move forward without any unresolved feelings tied to the jewelry.
  • Respectful Gesture: It showcases a level of maturity and mutual respect, emphasizing the value of the relationship and its memories.
  • Financial Fairness: In cases where the jewelry holds significant monetary value, returning it can be seen as an act of financial integrity.


  • Potential Emotional Turmoil: Meeting to exchange items might reopen emotional wounds or lead to unexpected feelings.
  • Miscommunication: Without clear communication, one party might misinterpret the intent behind the exchange, leading to confusion or hurt.
  • Logistical Challenges: If both parties have moved on geographically or emotionally, coordinating an exchange might be challenging.

Honoring the Past:

Choosing to exchange jewelry with an ex is a testament to the maturity and mutual respect of both parties.

It’s a nod to the significance of their shared history while also acknowledging the importance of moving forward independently.

This act, while simple, can be a powerful step in the healing and growth process for both individuals.

9. Store It Away Temporarily

Sometimes, the immediate aftermath of a breakup isn’t the right time to make definitive decisions about sentimental items.

In such cases, individuals might opt to store the jewelry away, placing it out of sight to give themselves the emotional space to heal and reflect.

By tucking it away in a drawer, box, or safe, they grant themselves the freedom to revisit the decision at a later time, when emotions have settled and clarity emerges.

This temporary respite ensures that any future decisions about the jewelry are made with a clear mind and heart, free from the turbulence of fresh heartbreak.


  • Time to Heal: Keeping the jewelry out of immediate sight allows for emotional healing without constant reminders of the past.
  • Flexibility: It provides the option to decide the jewelry’s fate at a later, more emotionally stable time.
  • Preservation: The jewelry remains safe and intact, ensuring that if it holds future sentimental or monetary value, it’s preserved.


  • Delayed Decision: While it offers a reprieve, the decision about the jewelry’s fate is merely postponed, and the individual might face the dilemma again in the future.
  • Potential Emotional Relapse: Stumbling upon the stored jewelry unexpectedly can trigger a rush of memories and emotions.
  • Occupied Space: The jewelry might take up physical space, serving as a dormant reminder of the past.

A Pause for Perspective:

Choosing to store jewelry away temporarily is akin to pressing the pause button, allowing for introspection and growth.

It’s a gentle acknowledgment that while the past holds significance, the present moment requires focus and healing.

This act offers a compassionate approach to oneself, ensuring decisions are made with care and consideration.

10. Melt Down or Recycle

For those seeking a fresh start, melting down and recycling jewelry can be a transformative choice.

This process involves taking the original piece and repurposing its materials to craft something entirely new.

Not only does this sever the emotional ties to the past relationship, but it also aligns with eco-friendly practices, ensuring that valuable materials are not wasted.

Whether the end result is a new piece of jewelry or another form of art, the act symbolizes rebirth and renewal, turning remnants of the past into a creation that holds new meaning and purpose.


  • Symbolic Renewal: Melting and recycling can be seen as a metaphor for personal growth and transformation, turning old memories into a fresh start.
  • Eco-Friendly: Recycling precious metals and gemstones reduces the need for mining and aligns with sustainable practices.
  • Customization: The recycled materials can be used to craft a piece that aligns with current tastes and preferences, offering a unique and personal touch.


  • Costly Process: Depending on the design and craftsmanship required, melting and repurposing can be expensive.
  • Irreversible: Once the jewelry is melted down, the original piece is gone forever, which might lead to feelings of regret or nostalgia.
  • Potential Loss: The melting process might result in a slight loss of material, especially if not done by skilled professionals.

Embracing Transformation:

Opting to melt down and recycle jewelry is a powerful testament to one’s commitment to growth and sustainability.

It’s a proactive step that signifies the ability to reshape one’s narrative, turning past experiences into a foundation for new beginnings and creative expressions.

From Heartbreak To Healing: 5 Inspiring Stories

In this section of the article, we will be discussing five stories from different women sharing their experiences with jewelry from their exes.

With each story, we will learn how their actions not only helped them cope with the memories attached but also empowered them to move forward in unique and inspiring ways.

1. Sarah’s Repurposed Ring

Sarah, a talented jewelry designer, received a beautiful engagement ring from her ex-fiancé, Max.

After their breakup, she couldn’t bear to look at the ring, but she saw potential in its stunning diamond.

She decided to repurpose it into a breathtaking pendant.

Every time she wears it now, she’s reminded of her resilience and creativity, turning a symbol of a failed relationship into a symbol of her strength.

Sarah Repurposed Ring Story

2. Lisa’s Charitable Choice

Lisa had a necklace from her ex-boyfriend, Tom, that she no longer wanted to keep.

She chose to donate it to a local charity that supports survivors of domestic violence.

Lisa found comfort in knowing that the piece, once associated with her past relationship, was now bringing hope and happiness to someone else.

Lisa Charitable Choice Story

3. Emily’s Gift to Her Sister

Emily’s ex-husband, David, had given her a pair of elegant pearl earrings on their anniversary.

After their divorce, she decided to gift them to her younger sister on her wedding day.

The act not only symbolized forgiveness and closure for Emily but also strengthened the bond between the two sisters.

Emily Gift To Her Sister Story

4. Mia’s Cash for a New Start

Mia found herself in a financial bind after her breakup with Alex.

She decided to sell the expensive watch he had gifted her and used the money to kickstart her own business.

That watch, once a reminder of heartbreak, became a symbol of her newfound independence and resilience as an entrepreneur.

Mia Cash For New Start Story

5. Maria’s Buried Treasure

Maria had a necklace from her high school sweetheart, John, who had passed away tragically.

She couldn’t bring herself to wear it anymore, so she decided to bury it at the place where they shared their first date.

It became a beautiful tribute to their love and a way to find closure and peace.

Maria Buried Treasure

All these stories illustrate the diverse ways in which women choose to deal with jewelry from their exes, highlighting the uniqueness of each individual’s journey toward healing and closure.


Dealing with jewelry from an ex can be an emotional journey, but it’s essential to find a solution that resonates with one’s personal healing process.

From keeping it as a cherished keepsake to repurposing, selling, or donating it, there are numerous ways to navigate this challenge.

Some choose to wear the jewelry casually, appreciating its beauty, while others might opt for a symbolic gesture like burying it or recycling it.

Share Your Experience!

We’d love to hear about your journey with jewelry from past relationships. How did you choose to move forward? Share your story with us in the comments below.

Further Reading

Your friendly neighborhood. I do SEO (Freelance Content Writer), and sometimes I cook food.

Leave a Comment